Ellie Wilson, JIMS and the Truth Behind the Allegations: One Year After Daly, Why Are We Still Talking About Personal Disputes?

12 November 2026

Following the renewed controversy surrounding our lecture at Abertay University this year, and having just been informed that Mr McGarvey mentioned my name on BBC Radio Scotland this morning in what I understand was an unfavourable context, although I have not yet heard the broadcast myself, I feel it is time to address some of the allegations repeatedly made about JIMS and me personally. What concerns me most is how an important national conversation about fair trials, miscarriages of justice and the rights of accused people is increasingly being overshadowed by what I consider to be one individual's personal vendetta. Rather than discussing the serious issues within Scotland's criminal justice system, we are once again being drawn into personal disputes and accusations that deserve to be properly examined rather than endlessly repeated.

Last year, Abertay University received approximately 300 complaints about our lecture. As the reports confirm, the majority of those complaining had not only never attended the lecture but were not even students at the university. What also needs to be highlighted is that social media pages associated with Ms Wilson's group were actively encouraging their followers to submit complaints to the university. This was not simply a case of students raising concerns about something they had personally witnessed. Complaints were being actively solicited from people with no connection to the university, including individuals I believe have a longstanding personal grievance against me. Despite the considerable pressure placed on Abertay, the university conducted a full investigation, and none of the complaints were upheld. Yet here we are, another year later, hearing the same accusations repeated as though that investigation never happened. Surely the organised effort to generate complaints, and the motivations behind it, deserve scrutiny too.

I would welcome contact from independent, unbiased investigative journalists who are prepared to question both sides, examine the evidence and challenge the narrative rather than simply accepting and repeating what others have already reported. The situation at Abertay University demonstrates exactly why proper scrutiny matters. When the allegations were actually investigated, none of the complaints were upheld. Despite all the noise, public outrage and social media controversy encouraged by one particular individual and those associated with her, the allegations examined by the university were not substantiated. That should tell us something about the importance of investigating claims before presenting them as facts. I am not asking journalists to take my side. I am asking them to do their job, question everyone involved and establish the truth.

One accusation that keeps appearing is that JIMS is an organisation that harasses victims of sexual offences. I find this particularly troubling because I have yet to see evidence supporting such a sweeping claim. People repeatedly refer to "victims" (in the plural) being harassed by JIMS. Who exactly are these individuals? How many are there? What evidence exists that JIMS has harassed them? I am unaware of anything that would justify these allegations, but if someone has evidence, I would encourage them to provide it so that it can be properly examined.

I also want to address the situation involving Ms Wilson. My decision to become vocal about miscarriages of justice followed what happened to my partner and our family, including a vicious campaign of public harassment directed at me by one of his accusers. My partner continues to maintain his innocence, and I firmly believe him. We have evidence and witnesses supporting his account, and I will continue fighting to have that evidence properly examined. Separately, I have extensive evidence documenting the harassment I have personally experienced from one of his accusers, as well as evidence concerning her conduct towards other individuals, not just our family. I have already spoken publicly about this and published a video on my YouTube channel explaining what happened and presenting some of the information I have gathered. The reason I mention this in connection with Ms Wilson is that she was associated with both women who accused my partner. This is important context because my concerns about her conduct did not arise out of nowhere, nor did this dispute begin with a single comment I made on social media. I also have evidence that Ms Wilson and my partner's accusers were involved in establishing a separate group called GEMS, and I have serious concerns about how that group has subsequently been used to target people associated with me. This history is relevant to understanding how the situation developed, and I am prepared to provide all the evidence for independent examination.

I have never pretended to like Ms Wilson, nor am I obliged to. I believe her actions have caused considerable harm, not only to me personally but also to so many innocent families who have turned to JIMS for support. Yes, I once commented on a social media post that she did not give me a "victim vibe". It was one comment, expressing my personal opinion, among thousands of comments people make online every day. But why was my particular comment singled out and given so much attention? Why is nobody asking about the allegations made by another survivor, Hannah Stakes, who accused Ms Wilson of taking her work and presenting it as her own? What about the accounts circulating within survivor communities alleging that Ms Wilson was removed from groups following complaints about her treatment of other survivors? These are allegations that deserve proper examination, yet my single comment seems to be receiving all the attention. Why the same standards of scrutiny are not being applied to everyone?

I also want to make something clear about that original comment. There was another woman involved whom I unfortunately judged by association, and I have since apologised to her. I recognised that I was wrong to make assumptions about her, and I had no difficulty acknowledging that. I will always admit when I am wrong, and I have no problem apologising when I believe I have treated someone unfairly. But I do not believe that my opinion of Ms Wilson falls into that category. I have formed that opinion through what I have seen, heard and experienced, and her subsequent conduct has done nothing to change it.

I also understand that Ms Wilson was previously arrested and charged in relation to domestic matters. She now claims that those charges were dropped, although I have yet to see independent documentary confirmation of the outcome. I would welcome Ms Wilson providing written confirmation, such as correspondence from the relevant authorities, with any private information redacted, so that the position can be established accurately. If the charges against her were dropped, that should be acknowledged - the presumption of innocence applies to everyone. And once we establish facts - there is a question I would like Ms Wilson to answer. What exactly is she saying happened? Is she suggesting that the allegations against her were false or malicious? If so, is she acknowledging that people are capable of making false allegations against others, including allegations serious enough to result in arrest and criminal charges? Or is she simply saying that the prosecution did not proceed? These are two very different things, and I would be interested to understand her position. Charges being dropped do not automatically establish that an allegation was false, just as an allegation being made does not automatically establish guilt. That is precisely why the presumption of innocence and the right to a fair trial matter to everyone, regardless of who they are. I have never been arrested or charged with any offence, yet I am repeatedly portrayed as the villain in this dispute because of one social media comment.

Now, why is nobody examining how many posts and videos Ms Wilson has published about me, how frequently she has mentioned my name and how often she has displayed my face to her followers? She has publicised my personal social media profiles and encouraged people to direct their attention towards me in a manner I regard as harassment. What I find particularly disturbing is that, among those who claim to campaign against rape and sexual violence, some have repeatedly expressed wishes that I myself would be raped. The irony and hypocrisy are staggering. How can people claim to stand against sexual violence while wishing that very same violence upon a woman simply because they disagree with her? I would have thought that anyone genuinely concerned about protecting women from sexual violence would condemn such behaviour, regardless of who the target is. Yet somehow, this is the abuse I am expected to tolerate while being accused of harassment myself. Ms Wilson continues recording videos about me, and yes - I have responded to some of those videos because I refuse to sit quietly while accusations and personal attacks are directed at me. Yet somehow, my responses are being presented as evidence that I am the one actively seeking her out. How does that make sense? Am I not entitled to defend myself? Why is her repeated public commentary about me seemingly acceptable, while my attempts to answer those attacks or presents my side of the story are characterised as harassment? Surely anyone examining this situation fairly would look at who published what, when it was published and the context in which each response was made.

In one of her latest videos, Ms Wilson claimed that the entire dispute comes down to me being jealous of her and wanting to be like her. She has also suggested that I envy the number of followers she has on social media. Frankly, I find it embarrassing that someone making such childish and self-absorbed remarks is being given a platform in what should be a serious public discussion about justice. We are talking about fair trials, potential miscarriages of justice, families being torn apart and fundamental human rights, yet somehow the conversation has descended into allegations that I am jealous of another woman's appearance or social media following. Is this really the level of debate we have reached? And why are journalists and public commentators giving such personal nonsense attention instead of questioning the evidence behind the serious allegations being made? I have absolutely no interest in being like Ms Wilson, and the suggestion that I do says far more about Ma Wilson and the direction this dispute has taken than it does about me.

And, why is nobody questioning those among Ms Wilson's supporters who are now arguing that she must be right because she is "pretty and dressed well" and we are not? What kind of argument is that? Since when did someone's physical appearance determine their credibility, the truth of their allegations or whether their behaviour should be questioned? Have we really reached the point where serious allegations are judged by someone's looks rather than evidence? If anything, this demonstrates just how far the conversation has moved away from facts, fairness and the serious issues we should actually be discussing.

What I struggle to understand is how Ms Wilson has managed to gain so much public and media attention, to the point where her personal grievances are repeatedly being brought into a serious national discussion about justice. I have particular concerns about how this began, including her relationships with two individuals working in journalism at STV and The Times, which I believe played a significant role in bringing her allegations into the wider media. Since then, the accusations have been repeated and amplified across numerous platforms, often without what I would consider proper scrutiny. How has one person's personal dispute been allowed to overshadow a national conversation about fair trials, miscarriages of justice and fundamental human rights? Why are journalists and commentators giving credibility to arguments about jealousy, appearance and social media followers instead of examining the evidence behind the allegations? I am not suggesting that Ms Wilson should be prevented from speaking, but I am questioning why her claims appear to receive so much attention while the facts behind them receive so little. Surely the responsibility of journalists is to investigate, question both sides and establish the truth, rather than allow personal accusations to become the story.

What I find particularly irresponsible is that people continue repeating claims that JIMS harasses victims without making any attempt to establish the facts or seek our side of the story. A personal dispute between two women does not establish that an entire organisation is harassing victims. Repeating such an accusation without evidence is unfair to every volunteer, every family and every person involved in JIMS.

I am traumatised by what happened to my partner and our family. I have watched our lives fall apart, and I have had to fight for answers, support and justice while also dealing with public attacks and accusations against me. Do I always react perfectly? No. I am human. I get angry. I get upset. Sometimes I say things that I might have expressed differently with hindsight. But none of that changes why I started speaking out in the first place. Where is the system that should be helping families like mine? Where is the support for people who believe their loved ones have been wrongly convicted? Where is the protection for innocent people whose lives can be destroyed by allegations, whether those allegations are made in a courtroom or on social media? And why does the Scottish Government continue to ignore the concerns we have been raising?

Instead of examining these serious questions, some people seem determined to make the conversation about my personal opinions, my personality or a dispute with one particular woman. I believe this is exactly what Ms Wilson wants: for the entire discussion about fair trials, miscarriages of justice and the suffering of families to become a discussion about her. That is one of the fundamental reasons I disagree so strongly with her actions and the way she conducts herself. In my view, she has helped turn an important national debate into a personal dispute, drawing attention away from the very people and issues we should be discussing. Meanwhile, families are suffering. Children are growing up without their fathers. People are losing their homes, their livelihoods and their reputations. And the questions about fairness within our justice system remain unanswered. How could Wilson's personal vendetta be allowed to overshadow the serious questions about fairness within Scotland's criminal justice system. If the Scottish Government had properly acknowledged the concerns being raised by families, provided meaningful support and taken decisive steps to address the implications of the Supreme Court judgment, perhaps we would not be spending so much time fighting to have our voices heard.

Today, 12 November 2026, marks exactly one year since the UK Supreme Court delivered its judgment in Daly and Keir. That judgment raised fundamental concerns about how Scotland's courts had been applying sections 274 and 275 of the Criminal Procedure (Scotland) Act 1995 and the implications for the right to a fair trial under Article 6 of the European Convention on Human Rights. This was not some minor procedural disagreement. It was a judgment from the highest court in the United Kingdom concerning one of the most basic principles of justice: the right of an accused person to receive a fair trial.

I have been saying for more than two years that my partner is innocent and has been wrongly convicted. I know what happened to our family, I know the concerns we have about his trial, and I will continue fighting to have those concerns properly examined. I am not asking the Scottish Government to simply accept my word that he is innocent. I am asking it to acknowledge that wrongful convictions are possible, that the Supreme Court has identified serious problems with the previous approach to fair trial protections, and that there is a real possibility that people such as my partner have been affected. Surely that possibility alone deserves a proper response rather than continued uncertainty.

And I am far from alone. There are hundreds of families across Scotland raising concerns about the convictions of their loved ones. These are mothers, wives, partners, sisters and children who have watched their families fall apart and who are asking for answers. They deserve to be heard, treated with dignity and given access to clear information and meaningful support. The Government does not have to agree that every conviction is unsafe to recognise that these families deserve assistance and that potential miscarriages of justice must be taken seriously.

The petition I submitted to the Scottish Parliament has now 1,304 signatures, and we have received written responses from the Scottish Government and the Scottish Criminal Cases Review Commission. Those responses are important, but they are not the end of the matter. We need clarity about how many cases may be affected, what review mechanisms are available, whether the SCCRC has sufficient resources and what practical steps will be taken to ensure that people who may have been denied a fair trial have a meaningful opportunity to challenge their convictions in a timely manner.

If you have not yet signed my petition, please take a moment to do so:

Sign Petition PE2265 – Review Scotland's response to the UK Supreme Court judgment on fair trial rights in Scotland

Everything I do, personally and through my work, comes back to two things: truth and justice. I am not asking anyone to take my word for anything. I am asking people to examine the evidence, question what they are being told and stop treating repeated allegations as established facts. If there is evidence that JIMS has harassed multiple victims, produce it. If there isn't, perhaps it is time to stop repeating that accusation and start asking why it has been allowed to circulate for so long.

I will not be silenced by intimidation, personal attacks or the repeated circulation of allegations I dispute. But I also refuse to allow a personal dispute to become more important than the families whose lives have been devastated and the fundamental questions about fair trials that remain unanswered.

One year after the Supreme Court judgment, the question should not be whether people like me are entitled to speak out. The question should be what Scotland is doing to ensure that every person convicted of a crime received a fair trial, and what happens when there is reason to believe they did not.

That is the conversation we should be having. That is the conversation our Government should be addressing. And that is the conversation I will continue to fight for.

Marsha

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This field is mandatory

This field is mandatory

This field is mandatory

There was an error submitting your message. Please try again.

Security Check

Invalid Captcha code. Try again.

©Copyright. All rights reserved.

Information icon

We need your consent to load the translations

We use a third-party service to translate the website content that may collect data about your activity. Please review the details in the privacy policy and accept the service to view the translations.